…or how to potty train Kodi.
This is by no means a primer to potty training, but will contain ample references to matters related, so all ye uninterested parties, be warned and walk away!
Last year, Operation Potty started with grandeur and flopped miserably. In post-analysis, several reasons were cited for its failure
- Kodi hadn’t fallen into a peeing/pooping routine – it was still random and unpredictable.
- We always seemed to miss the timing by just a few minutes.
- We might have had some success if we sat with him long enough in the bathroom, but I had no patience for prolonging that bathroom time. After all it was summer, time to be playing outside, not sitting in the toilet all evening.
But though I shelved it for summer, I didn’t really stop trying. Every weekend we were home and whenever we fancied, we’d put him in underwear, but it was really no use. It was the same over and over. Missed timing, accident, cleaning up, frustration. Then my first trimester came and I was too exhausted to even think potty training, so the whole idea was scrapped again. During Christmas break, I revisited the topic one more time, with a lot more determination and resolve. We had to find what we were doing wrong and had to break the endless cycle of missed timing.
So I went with the tried and true method – bribing. If bribes can get you college admissions, surely they can buy you potty training?! We re-explained the whole process to Kodi – of how only babies use diapers and big boys use the toilet. I might have repeated a hundred times about how he should tell me and where he should pee. After revisiting the basics, we introduced the bribe. ‘Kodi, you pee in the toilet and you get 1 Barney sticker, you poop and you get 2. Deal?’ He sounded intrigued. It was the first time he was being rewarded for anything, so more than anything, he was curious about this whole game, I think.
Then it required a lot of discipline from us -
Unlike our previous tries, this method worked like a charm, right from the start!
My theories on why it worked…
- The lure of Barney stickers. We got out a fresh notebook for him, he picked the sticker he wanted, I put a date next to it, and a ‘good job’ with a star, made a huge deal and made him show it off to Bapa and all that. If he told us before he had to go, we doubled his bribe amount. Often during the day, I’d show him the notebook and marvel at how many he’d got already. That appealed to his vanity. The bribes made him feel it was worth his time to cooperate with us and try.
- His body was more regulated now, he was somewhat predictable.
- It was a case of I want to be a big boy like Amma. (Yes, to him, I am a boy. In fact, the whole world is comprised of boys, with the exception of Ukka who is a girl. But that’s not the point of this post. )
- Two and half seems to be some magic number around which a lot of toilet training comes automatically. So in the end, Barney might have helped only with motivation, the rest might have been his own readiness.
We left it at this before our India trip. I was hoping we could continue the process in India – after all, legend has it that toddlers come back from India trips fully potty trained.
Turned out to be quite the opposite for us. He refused to use the desi style bathrooms – the floor or the toilet. He wouldn’t use a western toilet unless it had the training seat on it, and we weren’t going to invest in that for just two weeks. So we were all over Pampers in India and I was quite disappointed about that.
Thankfully, when we got back, he picked up right where he had left off. I told his school that he seemed to be doing well and they gave it a try too. First couple of days, they kept his diaper on, and took him to the restroom every few hours. That worked, so they switched straight to underwear and we skipped the whole training pants phase! They used a diaper for his naps the first few days, but that turned out to be unnecessary, so now he is diaper free at naps as well.
It has been this way for a week now, and we only use one diaper a day, that too cloth, for night time. What a huge difference! Now I have to figure out what to do with all the money I’m saving ![]()
But, we’re still miles away from the real deal.
- He still does not tell me before he has to pee, I have to either time it or look for signs where he is fidgeting. He does tell me before he has to poop, so we’re okay there. Some mornings, though, he surprises me. Say I am in the middle of something when he wakes up, and it takes me 10 minutes or so to take him to the bathroom, he’ll wait till then and actually use the toilet for both purposes. I think he’s doing it unconsiously. It looks like, physically, he is ready. Just that he has to make the association and voluntarily exercise control.
- He still wont use any toilet that is not kiddie size or that doesn’t come with a trainer seat. Which means public restrooms are out! (Why don’t they have tot sized toilets in all public areas?) As of now, we keep our outings to 5 mile radius and drive home every 2 hours to give him a potty break! I am not exactly sure how to handle this part – do we buy one of those portable seats to carry around everywhere? (ewww!)
- Add to all this talks of stomach flu going around school. That might stall our progress.
But at this point, we’re definitely light years ahead of when Operation Potty started, which is why I have jumped the gun by posting this way before we’ve seen real success! Aryan’s Mom, K3, and others who may be in the boat that I was last year, if this posts helped you, you’ll let me know, won’t you?!


24 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 12, 2008 at 10:53 am
Rohini
I am in a similar spot. My brat was poop-trained at 2.5 but is still not all there for peeing. If not reminded, accidents happen. I’m getting tense now though because he starts a new school in April where they have a no-diaper policy…
—
oh! and I thought we were almost there. looks like the ‘almost’ period stretches out forever….
but they will take him to the loo periodically, right?
March 12, 2008 at 2:11 pm
mystic margarita
Am coming back to your post for refernece in the future. Good luck with the potty training – seems it’s on the right track!
–
I hope it stays that way!
March 12, 2008 at 3:16 pm
K3
Very enlighting. Kutie is 19 months, so I guess he has some time … but then I want to go back to India early next year, so I am not sure to have in trained by then or after? Another friend, told me that you will need to be very patient and ready to ‘clean up’ for months before they start showing any signs of learning (dont think she tried the bribe) – So with both honey and I impatient people, I dont know if we should delve into potty-training just yet. Anyway, I am saving this post link to refer back to when we officially start this … Thx for the post again! Will keep you posted. Hugs!
—
well, bribe or no bribe, I did clean up for months before and after! i think it is a combination of everything – their timing and your effort. some kids might be ready by 19m, kids in India seem to get trained by the time they’re 2. let me know how it goes!
March 13, 2008 at 12:16 am
Poppins
Hey ! We’re at the same spot (no surprises right?) I think you’re absolutely right about the timing, 2.5 years is some sort of magic number. Since I’m also “almost” there from the last 2 months or so, I guess it’s time to bring on the rewards. I’ve been contemplating whether to do
(a) stickers (she doesn’t have much interest, but your book idea is great), or
(b) a clear box with miniature toys (the cheap plastic ones) or
(c) Gems (her absolute fav, but definitely not mine)
—
and I tried to stay clear of candy-ish bribes, maybe if our ‘almost there’ stage continues forever, I will use that as the next step
K is not big on stickers either – it was the game factor that appealed to him. what you use as bribe doesnt matter, I think, the build-up is what counts
—
And regarding public toilets, I’m also dreading that. How I deal with it right now, is if we’re going to a relative’s house, I make her sit reverse or sideways on the potty and she can hold on to me. Believe it or not, I have not yet encountered an Indian seat so I don’t know how she will react.
—
tried holding him when he’s sitting, but he gets the feeling he might slip into the bowl any moment, and refuses to sit for anymore than 2 seconds
—
I also have with me a travel potty but like you said Ewww. But hey, Kodi can just stand and aim can’t he?
Have Bapa take over that part.
—
hehe! that’s a thought. the toilets are too high for him, he’d need a step stool for this purpose. and holding him up interferes with his comfort zone. but maybe now that he’s got the hang of things, I should train him standing up at home as well…
—
Ro, you just have to tell the helpers in Ayaan’s school to take him every hour to hour-half or so. Within a few weeks he might get a grasp of it and start telling them. Meanwhile you can put on training undies on him (They are washable, reusable cloth underwear with absorbable material inside). It doesn’t fully absorb but absorbs enough to prevent an embarrassing dripping accident. No point in making me feel ashamed at school. You get them at Mothercare.
—
good idea, I should look for these as well. I may have seen some online, can use them for night time and prolonged outings.
—
That’s what I’m doing with Poppin right now and so far she’s had maybe two accidents totally (if the help forgets to take her or if she goes too soon). I’m hoping that she starts noticing other kids and starts telling but I must ramp up the process at home as well.
Ok I think it’s time for me write posts on my own blog and stop writing mini posts here
—
heck, this is your space! write all teh mini-posts you want
—
March 13, 2008 at 12:39 am
Aryan's mom
Thanks for this post Kodi’s mom..I really liked it. Your are right that I am in the same boat..about potty training Aryan. He says SHIi..gets up and do it where ever he is. If we don’t notice him, he take paper and try to wipe it..ahhh really annoying..He is scared to sit in the potty seater. He cries and gets up. Another thing is he cannot do Shi by sitting. He has to stand up and do!!! Funny kid. Now that I am seriously thinking about putting him in day(Because of Language problem at home), I have to inculcate the potty training habit..
I have to bribe him be saying about Giraffe toy.
Poppins Mom’s suggestion about training undies, should help me for some days..
Anyway will soon be into Operation potty. I have already taken a print out of your post..Thanks again..
Hope kutti baby inside is kicking you..well
—
We first got the potty seat when he was 10mo, and at that time, like Aryan, he refused to sit on it, cried and wanted to be lifted off. It is the newness that bothers them. if you can get books on potty training – or watch sesame street online – that will get him familiar with the concept. you can do this for several days, and once he’s knows what the characters in the books do, introduce the seat so he can imitate what he read about. and those days, I wasnt really trying to train, just trying to cut down one diaper, so I’d put him on the seat as soon as he woke up. over a few days, it became a habit. maybe that approach might help you get a start?
March 13, 2008 at 12:44 am
Rohini
I have to talk to the teachers about that. Because usually they just wait for the kids to ask…
March 13, 2008 at 1:02 am
noon
Kodi – I have been irregular with reading posts. Random more like since I don’t have google reader or anything set up. Less time these days as well – since KG is more active and sleeps much less.
Anyways – it was so good to see this post. I am so afraid of this process. I feel like my days are so filled with things to do as it is how will I deal with accidents…that too in a bi-level house and with KG being more active and me having to watch her all the time…it is so night marish for me. And I have a bunch of guests coming this month too…KB is now 2.5 yrs old and I HAVE to potty train him soon. It’s been chilly in Feb and he/KG had a cold etc so I postponed it – now I don’t want to do it when I have constant stream of visitors – am hoping this month end I will start…I have gotten him thinking about it thought with elmo can use the potty type – couple of books and making him sit there etc…I have bought a potty ring but I still have not used it for him. I am so nervous about this – am praying so much that he should get trained in a week or two like some people say they did for their kids…I just don’t know how I will manage accidents when a crawling baby who could hurt herself if I am not watching her! And how HATES being restrained when she wants to play!
Good luck – you have made a lot of progress as it is – wish you luck – your success story will give me a lot of moral support!
—
I completely understand, noon, I was also quite nervous and whenever friends said I just had to take the diaper off and forget abt it – I’d go ‘but what abt my carpet!’ trust me, a week after you start you wont be nervous or worried anymore, it will just fall into a pattern – or you’ll just get used to mess! but is KB’s body regulated? I mean can you somewhat guesstimate when he’s going to poop/pee? if not, regardless of how old he is, it still might be too soon to try.
I’ve also read that after a certain age (like KB’s age) some people train intensively for one or two days, and kids get the hang of it. you dedicate a whole weekend to it, when B is home so he can take care of other things. you explain the process to him with books and characters. then make him drink tons of water, and pretty much spend every hour in the bathroom. and of course reward and cheer extensively. they’re supposed to make the association very quickly.
another option, why not start with diaperfree only on wkends and wkday evenings when B is home?
—
March 13, 2008 at 3:26 am
Swati
I am also in the same boat. Helpful post indeed !!!
March 13, 2008 at 3:27 am
Swati
Hey ..what I wish to know in particular is ..how do you control when he is sleeping. Even if I manage when he is awake , I have no control when he is sleeping. IS KODI DIAPER FREE AT NIGHTS ?????
–
oh we’re years away from that! he is diaper free during naps (abt 3 hours), goes right before and right after, but at night time, I put a cloth diaper on him. the day I see a dry diaper in the morning, I’ll start considering night time training…before that I think it is too soon and pointless to even try.
March 13, 2008 at 10:38 am
Upsi
I am grasping this all in. All ears.
you have the luxury of time!
(Just so you know).
–
good
March 13, 2008 at 2:57 pm
2bs mommy
As I read the post and the comments, I couldn’t help smiling that I am all done with the toilet training thing a few years back already! Can only sympathise with you all now
hehehe
Seriously, a good post for whoever is at that stage. And you are right if you train intensively over 2-3 days, then that’s all it takes for the toddlers to get nappy-free. That’s how it happened with both of my kids, I just picked a weekend when I had not planned anything else and they were almost trained by Monday. But I did inform at their daycare a week before, so that they could put them on the toilet seat every hour to get the child used to the toilet seat and they had already had some success before the weekend. I think the kids learn when they watch the other kids using the toilet at the daycare.
—
you don’t remember tantrums or potty training?! I’m guessing the 2 bs were born readymade – lucky mommy! and thanks for the tip, am sure one of us will find this useful.
March 13, 2008 at 8:08 pm
sandeepa
Hey this would a good one for DMC, remember someone asking there too and I had done a potty training post last year. But this one is better, has real good pointers.
Fortunately for S, the school did more work than me
–
Oh, I should dig up the archives for your post..will compile the comments and post on DMC soon
March 13, 2008 at 8:11 pm
sandeepa
And while travelling, don’t worry, you/the hybby can hold him to do his job. Till last year anyway I was not comfy with S going to public toilets in rest areas and so held her, which was uncomfortable but..sighh. For the hotels etc. you can carry the toilet seat.
–
not so much traveling, but just our regular weekend outings. the holding is not doing the trick as of now, have to figure out something else like Poppins’ suggestion!
March 14, 2008 at 12:10 am
CA
Stickers did miracles in Cantaloupe house hold too… there was no particular choice of stickers… I just used the address stickers sent from various organisations that were just piled in the house for potty training rewards.
and hey, the address stickers are a neat idea! he loves them too, maybe I’ll use this as the bait for next step!
Public toilet will always be tricky … Cantaloupe now has this unique idea where she HAS to visit the public toilet in every restaurant we visit … grrrrrrrrrr….
—
LOL! thats the opposite of the problem we have now
March 14, 2008 at 12:20 am
Poppins
LOL I liked CA’s idea of the address stickers, I still have tonnes of them with our US address.. Hmmmm. What does she know? I’ll tell her that they have Daddy’s name on them and they are very important.
OK done, am trying this weekend.
—
you’ll let us know how it went, won’t you?
and I’m thinking….very important stickers with Daddy’s name used for such a ‘noble’ cause – wonder what Daddy will have to say about that
March 14, 2008 at 12:21 am
Poppins
Oh and about standing and aiming, would he be willing to stand atop the toilet seat (with you holding him from behind) and aiming?
Sounds weird na? Guess I’m not ready for a boy
you’re right, am completely handing over that part to the Bapa
–
ewww! neither am I
March 14, 2008 at 8:45 am
Squiggles Mom
Hey heard the news. Congratulations!
–
the potty training news or the other big news?!
Thanks, SM!
March 14, 2008 at 9:27 am
lavanya
hai kodi’s mom(will stick to that for now) i catch up with some of ur posts when i find time. i must say they r extremely interesting….not the events as such but ur narration!! becoz i experience the same with my kids, but i wonder if i can ever narrate them in the way u do! my son anirudh 2 years and 2 months is not yet potty trained but i am not worried as i did with my daughter. i guess when children near their 3rd year, they r able to say before they pee, give or take a few months. and i would like to add that using diapers only when going out will not harm the training, becoz again, u can keep telling them that diapers r only for outings. my daughter was in this diaper-for-outingonly stage till she was three and when she started going to KG1(2 months after she turned 3) she was out of the diapers once for all.
—
hey, welcome! the events aren’t interesting enough? hmmm, now what do we do abt that
wait, do we know each other – something abt your email addr, let me write offline.
March 14, 2008 at 1:56 pm
ddmom
Incidentally D started p-t with Barney bribes as well. Not really bribe.. A story that Barney came in Mummy’s sapna and said he would be happy if D uses the toilet. Because Barney likes to be friends with big girls. And big girls don’t wear diapers. Sounds weird now, but hey it worked

She stayed on outing-only-diapers for a good month after being fully trained and for about 6 months during night time. This January she decided herself she did not need diapers during night time and will run to the toilet if she wants to in the night. She slept on a four fold old comforter for about a week. Wet it once and that was it
As you said, they will let us know when they are ready.
–
whoa, that was one elaborate Barney tale…and smart little D bought it?! you must be a good storyteller then
seriously, that was a nice spin…I guess we have to worship Barney after all! and that was a really quick transition to no diapers at all, even at night.
–
Oh, and on using public restrooms, I just bend down a little and she holds on to me. Have you tried stand p-p with Kodi?[Borrowed the term from D. She has been killing me with this question lately. Mumma - Why boys do stand p-p and girls do sit p-p. But sometimes boys also do sit p-p.. Why mumma? ok.. ok.. Won't corrupt your space beyond this.. ]
–
LOL! what I am equally interested in is how you answer this question. Yes, Mumma, pls tell us why!
–
March 14, 2008 at 11:02 pm
lavanya
oh i dint mean that!! i just meant that the way u put it, is amazing!sometimes as busy moms we just overlook some of our kid’s babytalk and i should say not only u r lucky to have kodi, but he is lucky to have u as well!! and yes, we do know each other.
–
hey, I was just kidding! and now that I know who you are, I must say I am thrilled and very much honored to read your comments! Hope you’ll write more often..
March 16, 2008 at 1:41 am
swati
hmmm… Aryan is too unpredictable…the day i feel he is atleast potty trained if not pee..he does it in diaper
plus we used a baby portable seat..so when we are out or on vacation etc ..he uses his diaper only.
for pee ..i dont know how to go about
—
guess it might be too soon for him. when Kodi was Aryan’s age, I had moderate success if I sat him on the seat right after wake up, right after naptime and right before bedtime. for the rest, just wait till he seems to have fallen into somewhat pattern. I’ve also heard taht without diaper or underwear, the kid learns much quicker.
March 16, 2008 at 10:34 pm
Kiran Manral
KM, the brat wasnt potty trained at all, when he started nursery. I had banged my head into walls trying to get him to say he needed to go. Add to it, his chronic constipation at that point, and he never could have a quick motion.
But am shamed to say the school trained him themselves and forced me to stop diapering him. You dont bother, they told me, just keep a couple of extra clothes in his bag and he will get trained.
What worked, I am told, was peer pressure. The other kids go to pee and tell the teacher when they need to poop. And he learnt. When the body is ready, the child will learn. All the best….
—
wish we all had a magic alarm that told us exactly when the kid is ready! am glad the school helped you with most of the process though, the intial stage is difficult..
March 18, 2008 at 12:06 am
Swati
Good going Kodi’s mom!!
And for the kiddo sized toilets, I guess some of the family restrooms have those little ones along side the usual adult ones. Why don’t you give it a try the next time you go to a mall?
–
yes, there’s absolutely no problem if we find kiddie sized toilets, my problem was that not all major stores have them. anyway, we’re okay now.
March 19, 2008 at 11:26 am
ddmom
Alright, you asked for it. Don’t blame me if this is too much information
I told her just the fact – Girls and boys have different susu’s. Thats why. But this girl is not convinced. She attempts to make stand p-p few times and is stopped just before the accident. After seeing her being bothered with it for few days, one day I removed the rugs and let her make stand p-p. That was it!! She started crying, p-p came out on my legs. p-p all over the floor. I don’t like it. End!!
Oh, but this girl did not stop there though. Every time papa uses the restroom, she will knock-knock and ask – Are you making stand p-p or sit p-p. Somehow she seems to have gotten over it the last week or so..
–
that girl of yours is an absolute riot! and you’re cool for letting her find her own way! her poor Papa though!
thanks for sharing, if faced with such awkward questions, this is exactly what I’ll do – be honest and direct and face the (hilarious) consequences